I will be discussing valid forms of arguments using conditionals. Remember, a conditional claim is “one that can be rewritten as an ‘if…..then….’ claim that must have the same truth-value.” There are two forms of arguments that are valid using conditionals. These are direct and indirect. A direct example of a valid reasoning with conditionals can be described as “If A, then B. It is A. So then it is B.” For example:
If you punch Jacob, he’s going to punch you back.
You punched Jacob.
So He punched you back.
This is valid because it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false.
An indirect example is the exact opposite. “If A, then B. It is not A. So it is not B.” For example:
If you punch Jacob, he’s going to punch you back.
You didn’t punch Jacob.
So He didn’t punch you.
These are the two ways to form an argument using conditionals. Hope that helps a little bit!
Saturday, October 9, 2010
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Chapter 7
2). Please discuss, in detail, what you learned from reading Chapter 7. Discuss at least 2 things you learned.
Chapter 2 discusses objections and different ways to refute an argument. I learned quite a bit this chapter though. The first thing I learned is how to answer every objection. Every time someone brings up a good point(objection), it is your job as the one making the argument to counter or answer it. For example:
Sean: We need to get more alcohol.
McGavin: We already have some.
Sean: Yeah, but there are girls coming over and they will drink some.
McGavin: So?
Sean: We will run out once they drink ours, so we should get more.
See, here Sean is raising objections which forces McGavin to answer them.
Another thing I learned about is using ridicule. The only problem with ridicule is that it doesn’t do anything to benefit the argument but rather just ends it. For example:
Sean: I hate girls. They all are all backstabbing b*tches.
McGavin: Why cuz you’re ex girl cheated on you? That doesn’t make them all backstabbing.
Sean: Yes it does. They are all the same.
McGavin: Yea, you should probably just turn gay then.
Here, McGavin doesn’t feel like arguing with Sean so he simply ends the argument by using ridicule.
Chapter 2 discusses objections and different ways to refute an argument. I learned quite a bit this chapter though. The first thing I learned is how to answer every objection. Every time someone brings up a good point(objection), it is your job as the one making the argument to counter or answer it. For example:
Sean: We need to get more alcohol.
McGavin: We already have some.
Sean: Yeah, but there are girls coming over and they will drink some.
McGavin: So?
Sean: We will run out once they drink ours, so we should get more.
See, here Sean is raising objections which forces McGavin to answer them.
Another thing I learned about is using ridicule. The only problem with ridicule is that it doesn’t do anything to benefit the argument but rather just ends it. For example:
Sean: I hate girls. They all are all backstabbing b*tches.
McGavin: Why cuz you’re ex girl cheated on you? That doesn’t make them all backstabbing.
Sean: Yes it does. They are all the same.
McGavin: Yea, you should probably just turn gay then.
Here, McGavin doesn’t feel like arguing with Sean so he simply ends the argument by using ridicule.
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
Chapter 6
I learned a lot about how claims can be combined and have counter claims or negations. For instance, compound claims are “one composed of other claims, but which has to be viewed as just one claim.” In my own zesty tell ‘em words, that means it is made up of two different statements within one claim. For example, if I said, “Andy skateboarded to Taco Bell or some other fast food place.” These are two different claims because one claim says Andy skated to Taco Bell. The other claim says Andy skated to some other fast food place.
There are also contradictions to claims which are defined in the text as “a claim that has the opposite truth-value in all possible circumstances.” This is pretty basic but an example would be “Andy has red hair” and the contradiction (or negation) would be “Andy does not have red hair.”
These are two of the topics discussed in the chapter but there are a couple others as well. Hope these examples helped a little bit. Later.
There are also contradictions to claims which are defined in the text as “a claim that has the opposite truth-value in all possible circumstances.” This is pretty basic but an example would be “Andy has red hair” and the contradiction (or negation) would be “Andy does not have red hair.”
These are two of the topics discussed in the chapter but there are a couple others as well. Hope these examples helped a little bit. Later.
Saturday, October 2, 2010
Chapter 5 Section B: Personal Experiences
I chose to talk about the criteria for accepting or rejecting claims. I will try to give my opinion as well as possible although I am still slightly confused and just got back from the homecoming tailgate. Go Spartans! Anyway, the best way to find information that is reliable is to trust ourselves and our own personal experiences that we have already encountered in life. As the book says, "our most reliable source of information about the world is our own experience." It is important to trust yourself because that is honestly the only person you can trust. On the other hand, the book uses a good example of when NOT to trust your own experience when talking about eyewitness. It is true because when something happens real quick like a criminal punching you in the face, it is going to be really difficult to get a good enough look to be sure that you can trust what you saw. Nonetheless, our own experiences are usually the best way to judge if we can accept a claim or not. The book sums this up the best:
-We accept a claim if we know it is true from our own experience.
-We reject a claim if we know it is false from our own experience.
EXCEPTIONS:
-We have good reason to doubt our memory or our perception.
-The claim contradicts other experiences of ours, and there is a good argument against the claim
-We accept a claim if we know it is true from our own experience.
-We reject a claim if we know it is false from our own experience.
EXCEPTIONS:
-We have good reason to doubt our memory or our perception.
-The claim contradicts other experiences of ours, and there is a good argument against the claim
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Advertisement
http://www.amplifyyourvoice.org/u/Mahayana/2009/9/5/ExtenZe-for-Women-no-actually-still-just-men
This ad is for women’s extenze. It is geared towards women and “electrifying their orgasms and revved up libido.” I disagree with this advertisement for a few reasons. First, for an argument to pass or be good, it has to provide good reason to believe the premises to be true. I don’t believe it’s true because nowhere in the ad do they provide scientific reasoning as to why it would work. Also, the book provides three reasons about whether to believe a claim: “Accept it, reject it, or suspend it.” I’m rejecting it because I believe it is false. Based on past experiences, I have seen many advertisements claim to do something but then in a year or so a scientific source proves that it is bullshit and most likely will do some type of damage to the consumer. Although this product could be legit, I personally don’t agree with it and therefore reject it.
This ad is for women’s extenze. It is geared towards women and “electrifying their orgasms and revved up libido.” I disagree with this advertisement for a few reasons. First, for an argument to pass or be good, it has to provide good reason to believe the premises to be true. I don’t believe it’s true because nowhere in the ad do they provide scientific reasoning as to why it would work. Also, the book provides three reasons about whether to believe a claim: “Accept it, reject it, or suspend it.” I’m rejecting it because I believe it is false. Based on past experiences, I have seen many advertisements claim to do something but then in a year or so a scientific source proves that it is bullshit and most likely will do some type of damage to the consumer. Although this product could be legit, I personally don’t agree with it and therefore reject it.
Monday, September 27, 2010
Repairing an argument
“I swim every day so I’m in good shape.”
This argument is on its way to being good but is missing a necessary premise. The missing premise is “Swimming is very healthy and gets you in good shape.” This is repairing the argument because: it makes it stronger, the added premise is plausible and would seem plausible to whom I’m speaking to, and the premise is more plausible than the conclusion. We can also add an indicator word “therefore,” to let us know the conclusion is coming. Now the argument would look like this:
“I swim every day. Swimming is very healthy and gets you in good shape. Therefore, I’m in good shape.”
This is a strong argument now because the premises are very plausible and definitely set up the conclusion. However, there are factors that could prove this false. For instance, what speed are we swimming? How many laps are being swam? Things like that could change whether or not an individual is in good shape. Nonetheless, most people who swim every day are going to be in pretty good shape.
This argument is on its way to being good but is missing a necessary premise. The missing premise is “Swimming is very healthy and gets you in good shape.” This is repairing the argument because: it makes it stronger, the added premise is plausible and would seem plausible to whom I’m speaking to, and the premise is more plausible than the conclusion. We can also add an indicator word “therefore,” to let us know the conclusion is coming. Now the argument would look like this:
“I swim every day. Swimming is very healthy and gets you in good shape. Therefore, I’m in good shape.”
This is a strong argument now because the premises are very plausible and definitely set up the conclusion. However, there are factors that could prove this false. For instance, what speed are we swimming? How many laps are being swam? Things like that could change whether or not an individual is in good shape. Nonetheless, most people who swim every day are going to be in pretty good shape.
Friday, September 17, 2010
Slippery Slope Fallacy (Content Fallacy)
The book doesn't go into very much detail about the specific fallacies so I did a little extra research as well. But I still couldn't find a very concrete definition of a content fallacy so if you understand it well please leave me a post with your interpretation. Anyways, the slippery slope fallacy is when someone assumes that one statement directly follows another statement. And when they do this, they do it without even making an argument of how or why the statement should follow. For instance, if I were to say, "I need to break up with my girlfriend. If I don't, she will probably cheat on me." This is a slippery slope because there is no argument or stated reasoning for me to assume she will probably cheat on me. The website nizkor.org stated the following:
"This sort of 'reasoning' is fallacious because there is no reason to believe that one event must inevitably follow from another without an argument for such a claim. This is especially clear in cases in which there is a significant number of steps or gradations between one event and another."
An argument like this cannot be valid. Remember, for an argument to be valid, it has to be impossible for the conclusion to be false and the premises true. The slippery slope fallacy is invalid because even if the premises are true, jumping to an assumed conclusion is false. Nizkor.org did a good job of showing this in a variable form:
1. Event X has occurred (or will or might occur).
2. Therefore event Y will inevitably happen.
"This sort of 'reasoning' is fallacious because there is no reason to believe that one event must inevitably follow from another without an argument for such a claim. This is especially clear in cases in which there is a significant number of steps or gradations between one event and another."
An argument like this cannot be valid. Remember, for an argument to be valid, it has to be impossible for the conclusion to be false and the premises true. The slippery slope fallacy is invalid because even if the premises are true, jumping to an assumed conclusion is false. Nizkor.org did a good job of showing this in a variable form:
1. Event X has occurred (or will or might occur).
2. Therefore event Y will inevitably happen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)